Things that don't make sense are probably wrong

84 posts / 0 new
Last post
Jared Alesi's picture
Things that don't make sense are probably wrong

When an idea is tested scientifically, argued logically, and rigorously probed for any intellectual value, and still makes no sense, it's probably wrong. I won't say always, as that is a surefire comeuppance, but usually. New age mysticism has zero scientific or logical merit. It's fake. All of history's gods are unproven, and most are nonsensical in nature. The safe bet is that they're fake. The same goes for conspiracy theories, most of which are unsubstantiated and ridiculous. They're false. Alternative medicine is no more effective than placebo. Fake. The list goes on.

It's simple. Is it factual in nature? (Making an objective, non-opinionated claim) Then apply the scientific method! For example: The claim that the Christian God exists is a factual claim. There's no verification of this, and scientific discovery tends to suggest otherwise. Even one discrepancy between it and reality means it's wrong.

Is it philosophical in nature? (Seeking to find a framework for how one or all should behave in certain situations) Then apply to the standard of human empathy. For example: Social Darwinism states that people with genetic imperfections are holding back humanity, so we should stop helping them because it's stalling the progress toward higher existence. Does it fit in with an empathetic worldview? No! Not even close. In other words, don't be Hitler.

Is it an argument to make a point? Examine it syllogistically. If the premises contain logical fallacies, it's wrong! Does the argument make sense? No? Scrap it. For example: The universe is complex. A watch is complex. A watch has a designer. Therefore, the universe has a designer as well. Therefore, God exists. This argument contains the following fallacies: false correlation, non sequitur, special pleading, argument from ignorance/personal incredulity, and a few others. Can you find them all? Regardless, the argument is trash.

Believing in falsehoods is pretty easy to avoid using these methods. The great thing about logic and science is that if used properly, they'll only ever make life better. Never in the history of humanity has ignorance solved problems better than knowledge. The more you know that is true, the better off you'll be.

Subscription Note: 

Choosing to subscribe to this topic will automatically register you for email notifications for comments and updates on this thread.

Email notifications will be sent out daily by default unless specified otherwise on your account which you can edit by going to your userpage here and clicking on the subscriptions tab.

jonthecatholic's picture
Is the scientific method the
xenoview's picture
JoC
jonthecatholic's picture
I don’t disagree with you
chimp3's picture
@JoC: For millennia
jonthecatholic's picture
You seem to not understand
Jared Alesi's picture
No, he's got it fine. You've
Jared Alesi's picture
Philosophy doesn't carry
Jared Alesi's picture
Well, the way I defined fact
jonthecatholic's picture
Okay then. Can you please
chimp3's picture
@JoC:
jonthecatholic's picture
Facts refered to by the OP
Jared Alesi's picture
You doubt that the scientific
jonthecatholic's picture
Actually, you simply proved
Jared Alesi's picture
Actually, history is pretty
jonthecatholic's picture
You misquote me. I didn’t say
Jared Alesi's picture
What you requested was
jonthecatholic's picture
The fact that you admit that
Jared Alesi's picture
No, that's pretty much how
jonthecatholic's picture
Let me ask then. Logic. Or at
mykcob4's picture
Nope JoC you are wrong. The
jonthecatholic's picture
You just admitted that logic
algebe's picture
@JoC: "the basic rules of
Jared Alesi's picture
I never claimed that logic
jonthecatholic's picture
Myk was the one who said that
Jared Alesi's picture
Am I somehow saying this
algebe's picture
@Jared Alesi: "rape isn't
jonthecatholic's picture
I think you misunderstand
Jared Alesi's picture
Rape has nothing to do with
jonthecatholic's picture
You said rape has nothing to
CyberLN's picture
1. Define ‘free will’.

Pages

Donating = Loving

Heart Icon

Bringing you atheist articles and building active godless communities takes hundreds of hours and resources each month. If you find any joy or stimulation at Atheist Republic, please consider becoming a Supporting Member with a recurring monthly donation of your choosing, between a cup of tea and a good dinner.

Or make a one-time donation in any amount.