Objective moral values may exist. A god doesn't.

115 posts / 0 new
Last post
Flamenca's picture
Objective moral values may exist. A god doesn't.

@Aposteriori Unum recently opened a thread called "A brief attack on the moral argument", in which he asserts that objective moral values don't come from any god and he adds: "I would argue that objective moral values don't exist." It seems like every atheist who has replied agree with that idea.

Although I'm aware of gods being fictional and that there's a subjective (and changeable over time and place) component of moral values, I'd like to defend my interpretation of Sam Harris' ideas about the possibility of discerning objective moral values through Science, and that objective moral values already exist in a way. @AUnum is a guy who uses Harris' face in his profile, so I'll better roll my sleeves up.

These objective moral values come from a place of subjectivity (death is not always morally wrong in every society, depending on scenarios such as war or death penalty where it's legal) but we -as a species- are able to establish which values should be considered objective, and we have a tool called Science which can help.

This is the main idea in my own words about three months ago: "According to Harris, moral and immoral (good and bad) can be measured by these factors: The worst possible misery for everyone (that would be objectively "bad") and the moral (good) thing to do is to avoid the "worst possible misery for everyone" and look for the well-being for everyone.

Well-being comprehends several factors, that can be objectively measured, so we don't have to depend on different subjective opinions. In this sense, there would be then a scale in between, in terms of good-bad, in which the worst possible misery for a majority would be a little less bad, but still not completely good... etc. If your beliefs cause suffering to anyone, then they shouldn't be considered moral. And the more people suffer because of that, the more immoral they should be considered".

I also want to add that objective moral values already exist, since we have legal systems, which could be considered also achievements in terms of social well-being and that they are basically the development of moral codes, catalogs of wrong behavior in society and the specific punishment to those who misbehave. So I'm just talking about going one step farther (and always "one god further") so to extend the Human Rights Declaration (and that of the Animal Rights) based mainly on a scientifical basis.

If we want a better world, a world with as less suffering to beings as possible, and free of religious commandments, the pursuit of an objective morality -based on different moral criteria than those inherited from religion- is crucial.

Subscription Note: 

Choosing to subscribe to this topic will automatically register you for email notifications for comments and updates on this thread.

Email notifications will be sent out daily by default unless specified otherwise on your account which you can edit by going to your userpage here and clicking on the subscriptions tab.

Nyarlathotep's picture
Making objective moral codes
MCDennis's picture
My sisters Nina and Nancy
Flamenca's picture
@Nyar, it's not different
ʝօɦռ 6IX ɮʀɛɛʐʏ's picture
What if you use statistics to
Sheldon's picture
Except once most of the world
mykcob4's picture
I totally and respectfully
Aposteriori unum's picture
Are they objective or can one
Flamenca's picture
@Aposteriori Unum: Are they
Sushisnake's picture
@Flamenca
Flamenca's picture
@Sushi. I'm glad that you get
jonthecatholic's picture
I find this exchange very
Aposteriori unum's picture
I only use the analogy
Nyarlathotep's picture
Kind of sad you had to
bigbill's picture
I say that moral values are
Aposteriori unum's picture
Wow... How insightful and
Old man shouts at clouds's picture
Here's a troll. Do Not feed
Flamenca's picture
Hi, @AB. I would be delighted
bigbill's picture
hia, well look at the
Sheldon's picture
Could you stop making
bigbill's picture
you croon over the eventual
Nyarlathotep's picture
agnostic believer - haven`t
Sushisnake's picture
@Nyar
algebe's picture
What does "crinch" mean? How
Sheldon's picture
"you croon over the eventual
bigbill's picture
and tell me doctor and what
Sheldon's picture
"The American College of
Sushisnake's picture
@AB
algebe's picture
@Agnostic believer:
jonthecatholic's picture
Hey. Maybe check on Leah
Sheldon's picture
"I say that moral values are

Pages

Donating = Loving

Heart Icon

Bringing you atheist articles and building active godless communities takes hundreds of hours and resources each month. If you find any joy or stimulation at Atheist Republic, please consider becoming a Supporting Member with a recurring monthly donation of your choosing, between a cup of tea and a good dinner.

Or make a one-time donation in any amount.