Moral Dilemmas of an Undergraduate

13 posts / 0 new
Last post
HigherEdPlanetEarth's picture
Moral Dilemmas of an Undergraduate

My older brother raised me after my parents passed away, so he's a lot like a father to me. He invited me to dinner. We had a great time. But on the car ride home he said he wanted me to go to college again. The only problem with that is I hate school. I never liked it, even as a young child I never wanted to go. I always thought up excuses as to why I couldn't go. At the same time though, I want my father figure to be proud of me, which, while I was going to school, he told me every day how proud he was, which made me really happy. But I felt like I was there more for him than I was for me. What should I do? Should I go to college at the expense of my own happiness? Or do I let my older brother down? I don't know what I should do. Do you have any advice for me?

Subscription Note: 

Choosing to subscribe to this topic will automatically register you for email notifications for comments and updates on this thread.

Email notifications will be sent out daily by default unless specified otherwise on your account which you can edit by going to your userpage here and clicking on the subscriptions tab.

CyberLN's picture
What about school do you

What about school do you dislike so much?!

Capt.Bobfm's picture
What are your prospects for

What are your prospects for your future ?
Who's paying for college ?
Most importantly, What do YOU want to do ?

bighugedave's picture
Hello Valencia,

Hello Valencia,

My opinion on the matter is you should probably just talk to your brother, have a heart to heart conversation, and tell him pretty much what you said in your original post. I'm sure if he knew what kind of pressure that puts you under, and that you really want him to be proud of you, that he would be understanding. Sometimes the best thing to do is to just tell the other person how you really feel instead of keeping it all inside where no one really knows for sure how you're feeling. He probably has no idea of how unhappy you'd be if you did go back to school. Or maybe you already told him?

Either way I think you should do what you feel is right for yourself, not someone else. It would be great if everyone accepted us the way we are, accepted our choices, and forgave our mistakes. But unfortunately life isn't like that. The best thing you can do is to enjoy life as much as possible doing what you feel is right for you, and try not to be too hard on yourself if someone else isn't in agreement with your life choices.

Of course it's always easy to give advice on matters like this. But I've had the same issues with my own father and finally realized I can't worry about doing everything that would make him happy. It makes for an unhealthy relationship when you're always worried about that sort of thing.

Take care,

David

Mangal Das's picture
Dear Valencia Bence,

Dear Valencia Bence,
Go to college and it is nice place ,you will make new frnds, It will be helpful in your future. You may not understand the value of education today. But good education is a foundation for better life.

Travis Hedglin's picture
This is YOUR life, if you do

This is YOUR life, if you do not do what YOU would really like to, YOU'RE the one who will die with regrets. No matter how nice or wonderful your brother may be, he will neither share those regrets, or be able to alleviate you of them. It is YOUR life, YOU must live it in the way YOU see fit, as that is the ONLY way that YOU will be happy with it.

Khaled Ben Youssef's picture
i know college is boring for

i know college is boring for you its not so interesting but try to found the positive part and interesting part of it ,like make friends change thoughts with other A minds ..and in the end believe it knowledge is priceless.

Jeff Vella Leone's picture
ValenciaBence

ValenciaBence

School is boring and frakly not as agood as one might think, however, it is a guidline for the starting of new experiences and things that maybe you don't evn know they exist yet.

one could say that instead of learning things on your own, you have a tutor that guide you in the process, corrects your mistakes etc..
So do not see school as an obligatory thing but as a way to improve your social status, to be like your brother.
One day when you have your own kids, you would want to have as much knowledge as possible to make it easier for them then it was for you.

Look at the sacrifices your brother had to make for you, think of you being in that position and what if you could improve those conditions from when you are still young.

It is indeed an investment for your family.

You can also think that one day you might be able to repay your brother in some way, and what better way would be to show him that you can not only stand on your two feet but thrive with a successful career.

nothing would make him more happy.

You will look back on your decision in some 10 years and say I am happy today for the sacrifices I did 10 years ago or not?

Anonymous's picture
Valencia-Why are you here????

Valencia-Why are you here?????? Asking advice from strangers is really dumb. First of all you know nothing about anyone in this forum. Are they republican, democrats, socialists communists, child molesters, murderers, bank robbers, priests, or assholes. Are they atheists, agnostics, "creationists, Christians, Moslems, fanatics of any religion. Maybe they want to join ISIS or think they will go to paradise if they kill enough infidels. Worse than you asking for advice from anyone who may be a moron are "atheists" or theists in this forum who think they know you to really offer intelligent advice. You know more about you than anyone especially the know it all's in this forum. In fact don't take advice from me as I may be an idiot. If you ask some in Atheist Republic they will say to be wary of me as they really think I am an idiot. But I know I am an intelligent, perceptive, handsome, creative, interesting, happy, nice, lovely and empathic human being. God Bless ......................................................P.S. Some of the advice given to you from the "members" in this forum are so obvious "it" is silly. ... Especially Jeff---He thinks he "knows" things all the time.

Kataclismic's picture
-----------------------------

-------------------------------------------------
Public information announcement(from Pragmatic):
-------------------------------------------------

"fred,k" is actually the infamous troll of the Atheist Republic forum.

Generally referred to as "Kenny", has been banned many times under different names.
Previously known aliases include: "Kenny Schweiger", "Kenny", "myself", "alleycat", "richardd", "Christopher", "marken", "punkin", "amber", "Simon".

Claims to be an atheist. But he has a fondness for using "sarcasm", even though no one ever gets his sarcasm and he has been told this many times, he keeps posting such deceiving comments.

He seems obsessed with religions, creationists and the stupidity of Fox News, Bill O'Reilly, Joel Osteen, Ted Cruz, Sean Hannity, Donald Trump, Vanna White, Sarah Palin, etc.

This announcement will be posted whenever he spams, agitates, confuses or flies off the handle.

Also, he finds these announcements 'boring'.

Anonymous's picture
Kataclismic--BORING

Kataclismic--BORING-Your picture has a resemblance to a rodent.. I just can't figure which one --although I have an idea. God Bless

Kataclismic's picture
fred,k,

fred,k,

I'm just spreading information, you're just attacking people on a personal level because you're an attention seeker.

Anonymous's picture
God Bless you silly

God Bless you silly

Donating = Loving

Heart Icon

Bringing you atheist articles and building active godless communities takes hundreds of hours and resources each month. If you find any joy or stimulation at Atheist Republic, please consider becoming a Supporting Member with a recurring monthly donation of your choosing, between a cup of tea and a good dinner.

Or make a one-time donation in any amount.